2016: The Perfect Storm?

May 20, 2016 By: Primo Encarnación

As we noted earlier, close elections like the two for Dubya earlier this century are unusual, and since 1912, all but 4 victorious Presidents have had Electoral College wins north of 300 electoral votes (EV). Of those 22 wins, about 2/3 of them – fourteen – have been what we defined as “blowouts” of over 400 EV. And three have been “huge” at over 500 EV for the winner.

It will take a lot of work for Hillary to reach the 400-vote benchmark, and due to the current Republican strongholds in the Deep South and in the Northern Plains, general election wipe-outs where the loser wins only one or two states seem highly unlikely. But the small populations (and, thus, small EV prizes) of those states make it possible that Trump could win several states, and still take home fewer than 39 electoral votes.

What would that look like?

First, win all the toss-ups from our previous map. That would give Hillary 470 EV. The key to all that, of course, is minority turnout in places like Texas, Georgia and the Chicago burbs of Indiana. She’d have to win AR as a home state, and carry states like KS and LA based on the failed GOP governance there.

Then, to get the 30 remaining votes she needs, she’s going to have to build off the momentum she gained in GA, MO, IN and AR to draw in Kentucky and Tennesee, for an additional 19 EV. In declining order of switch-ability, the states remaining to Trump that she’d then have to gain another 11 votes from are: NE (4 more EV, we already gave her 1), WV (5), AK (3), OK (7), SD (3), WY (3), MS(6), AL (9), SC (9), ND (3), MT (3), ID (4).

Can all this happen?

Not unless Trump helps by being so patently, obviously, completely an unqualified candidate that GOP voters stay home in droves in every damn state. This is not a difficult case to make, obviously, but it is a very difficult case to sell.

It has gotten a lot harder in the last week as GOP folks, for the most part, seem to be falling in line behind Trump, and the Never Trump movement has run out of steam. Trump’s support in the primaries has been shown to be the same old hard-right mouth breathers that have formed the snacilbupeR base since Nixon, only now they are turning out for primaries rather than just in November. This bespeaks a small but energized base who can cause a lot of trouble in tiny states like we’ve listed here.

What does the historical precedent look like?

The three times this has happened (1936, 1972 and 1984) it’s been done by sitting Presidents running for re-election who won their first term by at least 300 EV (two by 400+ blowouts) and were building on that basis. Their opponents have been selected by contentious primaries, and the electorate was facing hard times, but times they felt were getting better under the current President. Each sitting President had been elected as a repudiation of the other Party based on those hard times.

How is this year different?

Besides none of those historical conditions obtaining, the electorate is a lot more polarized, and a lot more diverse.   This means that rising minority participation is helping to raise Democratic numbers, but hard-right enclaves make it more difficult to pull some states out the red column and into the blue. Furthermore, Hillary Clinton, while building on the popularity of the Obama Administration – essentially framing herself as a third Obama term – carries high negative perceptions herself. Combined with coming off a contentious primary of her own, it seems highly unlikely that massive turnout will propel her to a high-end victory over 500 EV.

What elements could contribute to the Perfect Storm?

  • Let Trump be Trump – and also let him be so bad that it overcomes the cognitive dissonance that has held the GOP coalition together since Reagan.
  • Perception: The media “horserace” narrative must be overcome – this is not an even fight between two differently-qualified individuals. It is a fight between qualified and not; between engaged and not; between Presidential and not. There’s not enough honest media to present that, so it will have to be overcome by hard work and lots of ads. And by folks like us.
  • Depressed GOP turnout – especially among women, who will be subjected to months of Trump’s misogyny. The risk with that is that, after awhile, it just blends into background noise. But we might also see lower turnout also among Trump’s base, low-information white males, who may find the effort to vote in a losing cause too egregious to bear.
  • Strong Dem turnout and some crossover GOP votes – especially among women and minorities.
  • Vice Presidential nominees – although they rarely have an effect on the race, especially with the “home state” nonsense, sometimes they DO have an effect. The right VP pick could ensure greater women and minorities turnout for Hillary. The wrong VP pick could utterly destroy Trump. Consider – I can’t believe it’s even a thing, but there it is – a Trump/Palin ticket.   Just, stop reading for a minute, put your hands in your lap, and consider it. Back now? Did the score “538-0” enter your mind?
  • Election strategy – Trump is the king of earned media and very little else in the professional political toolkit. His understanding of the election is based on the air war, and so far he hasn’t shown a lot of organizational skill. He just now hired a pollster, but I believe that will be less for micro-targeting and more for lying about internal poll numbers showing him doing better than he is. In other words, for more earned media. Hillary should be able to out-organize him everywhere.
  • Will – you can’t just sit back and wait for all 50 states to come to you. Team Hillary and the Democratic Party must full embrace Dean’s 50-state strategy and CHALLENGE EVERYWHERE. In this election, especially, the best defense is a good offense. Challenging in KY and WV shores up Ohio and Michigan. Challenging in South Dakota shores up Wisconsin. Challenging in the South shores up the mid-Atlantic and flips Georgia.

Come on, Primo, is all this gonna happen?

It really would have to be The Perfect Storm. That’s highly unlikely, although I think 400 is eminently do-able. The beauty of that is that the same strategy you would use to reach 500 guarantees you 400, and also helps all your down-ticket races.

But the whole key to everything, the reason I have believed from the start that Hillary would not only be the nominee, but also President of the United States, is because of the women’s vote. As we’ve noted in the past, the percentage of women in the November electorate has been rising slowly, but steadily, up to around 54%. Obama got 55% of that, which equates to a 5.4 percent head start in final totals. If Hillary, thanks to Trump’s big mouth, can pull in 60% of the women’s vote, that’s an 11% boost.  There are 8 women who are potential freshmen Democratic Senators.   What an exciting prospect!

So many things would have to go right for Hillary and wrong for Trump for the Democrats to pull off their first 500 EV Perfect Storm since FDR. I just don’t think we’re going to get there.  But for the first time in 84 years, it’s a conversation we can finally have.

And there’s always Hillary’s re-election in 2020!

Chat

May 19, 2016 By: Juanita Jean Herownself

Guys, I got called in to work at the ballot board this morning.  Chat amongst yourself.

Obamacare: Bite Me

May 18, 2016 By: Juanita Jean Herownself

So, there’s a virus being spread by a mosquito.

“Senate Democrats tried and failed Wednesday to expedite emergency funds to combat the Zika virus, stymied by Republicans who objected and tried to extract cuts to Obamacare as a condition for their agreement.”

Well done, Senate Democrats, well done.  Bite me.

Thanks to Alan for the heads up.

They Say It’s True

May 18, 2016 By: Juanita Jean Herownself

.

Obituary in Richmond, Virginia.  Click here to read it all.

 

Screen Shot 2016-05-18 at 3.27.34 PM

It’s real.

mY7R6lZ

He Just Wants To Say SEX a Whole Lot

May 18, 2016 By: Juanita Jean Herownself

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who is under indictment for about 20 different felonies and is a real sinker, has gone all sex sex sex over the gender neutral bathrooms thing.

ken-paxton-mugFirst off, I do not want my kids to go to any of the bathrooms with Ken Paxton. I don’t trust the guy. He’s creepy.

Paxton got semi-famous because his wife goes around to Republican meetings singing, “I’m a pistol packing momma and my husband sues Obama,” which sounds vaguely threatening to me and totally goofy. You can hear it here but I’m warning you, it’s not music, it’s noise.

Anyway, before I forget where I’m going here, Paxton is a’blaze with indignation that President Obama says we should be respectful of our neighbors.  That must be something out of that Muslim stuff because Christians like Ken Paxton say it’s okay to love America but hate Americans.

Anyway, Texas stands to lose again.  Our Governor, our Lt. Gov., and our Attorney General all three say we ain’t gonna let people decide what gender they are because people like them would lie to to see women peepee.  Or that creepy people would hang out in bathrooms looking to do dirty stuff, you know, like Republican politicians.

It stands to reason that since apparently Republican politicians have raunchy ideas and deeds, that maybe we could just bar them from using any public bathrooms.

If Texas Republicans decide that they want to dig in their heels, which seems likely because they are mostly heels, we lose $6 billion in federal funding.  But, look, people dying because we don’t accept our Medicaid funds from the federal government doesn’t bother Republicans, so you think ignorant kids will bother them?

Sumbitches.

 

Will 2016 be a Hillary blowout?

May 18, 2016 By: Primo Encarnación

What is an Electoral College blowout?

I am defining an Electoral College blowout, somewhat arbitrarily, as 400 EV. Since the number of electoral votes first went above 500 in 1912, the winner has won by a blowout, surprisingly, 14 times! In fact, it’s extremely rare that a President wins with less than 300 EV; that’s only happened 4 times (twice with Dubya) compared to the 3 times in these last 26 elections that the winner has achieved 500 or more electoral votes, what I am calling the Perfect Storm.  So a winning electoral college map above 300 votes is actually the norm!

Doesn’t Trump shake up the map?

Not in a good way for Republicans, because the Trump path to winning the election is not new, it’s not revolutionary and it’s not going to work.

Politico has been doing some deep dives into some of the primary data and has discovered a few things: 1) The new voters that Trump is bringing into the process are really old voters who usually vote in November but rarely vote in primaries.  2) The percentage of Democrats crossing over to vote in the GOP primary is no bigger than the usual amount 3) The number of actual new GOP voters in this cycle is no larger than normal, either.

What this means is that Trump is not putting any blue states in play simply by being Trump, so from the GOP standpoint, this is going to turn into another long slog trying to defend former red states that demographics are turning increasingly purple, while trying to peel off recent purple states that are turning increasingly blue.

In reality, what this means is that the 300+ electoral votes that Obama won in each of the last two elections have actually conformed to the historical norm, and is likely to continue that way, for Hillary, especially as Trump and the GOP continue to weaken recent red strongholds.

Here’s how I see the current starting point, broken out by region.

I'm serious!

 I’m serious, you guys!

East-Northeast: From Maryland north and east, including PA – all those states have been solidly in the Democratic column since 1992, except for NH in 2000 (thanks, Nader!) Nothing is going to change that.  Regional EV for Hillary: 112

Upper Midwest/Rust Belt: From Ohio west and north to Minnesota – we lost Ohio in 2000 and 2004 by 3 and 2 points, respectively.  We’ve won it by 5 and 3 points since.  Other than that, Indiana is the only state in this bunch consistently voting red, but not always.  Not counting IN, regional EV for Hillary: 80.  Toss-up: 11

Appalachia/Old South: From West Virginia south and west to the Mississippi – this has mostly been an area of red dominance with a few swing states thrown in.  Bill Clinton did okay here as Bubba.  Florida has been moving blue since 1996, with the GOP only winning there in 2004 (in 2000 they cheated).  Virginia has been breaking blue lately and NC has turned into a swing state.  It will remain in Hillary’s column, thanks in part to bathrooms.  The rest will remain red, for now, except Georgia, which is turning into a swing state.  Regional EV: Hillary 57, Trump: 48, Toss-up 16.

TransMississippi: From Kansas south and east to the river – this has been solidly red, of late and probably will remain so except for a couple of factors.  Kansas and Louisiana as GOP/ALEC laboratories of dumb are in really bad shape.  The recent elections in LA give us hope.  Arkansas, it’s hard to say: they like Bubba but Hill was never as popular there.  Still, it’s one of her “home” states.  Missouri has been threatening to be in play for awhile, and Texas, well, wtf you guys?  Will we ever mobilize the Hispanic vote?  Economic trends, bad GOP stewardship, changing demographics, as well as the possibility of a Texas VP pick for the Dems keep everything in this area as a toss-up (leaning red) in my estimation, except for OK.  Regional EV: Trump 7, Toss-up 68

The Northern Plains: From Nebraska north and west to Idaho – this has been red and will stay red, except for the odd vote-splitting in Nebraska, which will net Hillary 1 EV.  Throw Alaska in for good measure (although, ya know?  Alaska is weird sometimes) and this is the best part of the November 8 for Trump.  Regional EV: Hillary 1, Trump 23, Toss-up 0.

The Four Corners: CO, NM, AZ, UT and add in Nevada – this region has seen the most movement from red to blue, of late, as Colorado, New Mexico and Nevada have trended that way for Obama, in part thanks to the growing Hispanic vote.  I believe AZ will also move blue this time, leaving Utah the lone red stalwart in the area – or is it?  Mitt Romney and the Mormons are SO anti-Trump, that I’ve moved this state into the Toss-up column.  Regional EV: Hillary 31, Toss-up 6.

The Left Coast – CA,WA, OR, HI – nothing to say other than Regional EV: Hillary 78.

Which brings us to Hillary 359, Trump 78, Toss-up 101

Will 2016 be a Hillary blowout?

Well, she’s well on her way to one. In order to get to this jumping off point, she has to defend the recent gains like OH, VA and FL, shore up WI and MI, and win new swings like AZ and NC.  Then she has to start creating new swing states like GA and Texas.

Picking up the 41 votes she needs to reach 400 will be difficult without Texas, but still do-able. She will challenge hard in TX, LA, GA and IN, and hope to get lucky in the remaining toss-ups by making Donald Trump play defense in areas where the GOP has lately been having to spend more time.  If she starts to get traction in KY and TN, look out!

But Texas is the key to a new liberal hegemony. If we flip Texas, it’s “Katy, bar the door” and we’re off to the races in search of 500, the Perfect Storm.

Next: The Perfect Storm (this post got too long)