Parallelism
Sometimes it pays to pay attention to what is going on around the world. Many people that think of Haiti probably consider in the same category our ex-president considers them in. When we get wrapped up in our daily lives we often don’t give places like Haiti a second thought.
We probably remember the earthquake that rocked Haiti back in 2010. Twelve years later and I don’t give it a second thought. At least I can say that was true before watching a video in the World Geography class I support. Haiti shares an island with the Dominican Republic and those countries couldn’t be more different.
The obvious result was droves of Haitians leaving Haiti searching for somewhere to go. A number of them came here and in the United States. So, few if any of us thought to consider the Dominican Republic. We probably just assumed they would do the neighborly thing. In some cases they did, but their reaction also showed the dark side of these events.
It’s hard to view their collective reaction as anything other than racism. Of course, we are only viewing it from the Haitian perspective. The Dominican Republic had been a relatively well run country and they didn’t want a human tragedy to take them down with them. Of course, there were a number of horrible events that led up to that moment.
A bunch of 9th graders probably can’t appreciate all of the implications of such a video. They may think of Haiti as one of those places where you can sponsor a child like Sally Struthers used to do. Just 72 cents a day can feed and educate a Haitian child. However, the deeper you look, one cannot possibly avoid seeing parallels to our situation here.
Those huddled masses yearn to breath free. Haitians wanted a better life. On an individual basis it wasn’t their fault that life was so brutally tough in their home country. Collectively things are never that simple. They were victims of things out of their control, but they also did plenty to create their own problems.
The Dominican Republic’s collective response was to render some aid but ultimately to block as many people from coming as possible. That by itself has some justification. If we allow your crappy country to export all of its citizens to our country then our country becomes the crappy country. At least, that’s the thinking behind it.
Xenophobia has rarely been so fully on display. The ties that bind is the notion of “not in my backyard.” That was a phrase coined by George Carlin years ago in his comedy act. The general idea is that we want what’s best for people and we don’t want anyone to suffer. We see the constant barrage on television of the plight of abused animals, polar bears without ice to stand on, or children with cancer. We see the plight of poor children on the other side of the world.
We will give anything to erase those images from our brains. 72 cents a day (or whatever it really is) doesn’t seem like a lot. Maybe if we all chip in we can really make a difference. That line of thinking stops when the problem comes closer to home. I’m really sorry you are going through so much, but if you could go through it somewhere else that would be great.
So, at the end of the day we really can’t shame the Dominican Republic. They did what we do. They just put an official stamp on it and called it a name. Sometimes, other people far away provide us with a window into our own soul. Looking at life through that window hopefully evokes at least some level of shame. That is the case if we have any ounce of humanity left.
One island with two sovereign nations, what could possibly go wrong there? Long standing historical mistakes that have arrived to bite us square in the tuchis. Not dissimilar from some of our other historical mistakes that eat at our credibility and threaten to gnaw off our toes where we’ve divvied up land among ourselves that actually belongs to indigenous peoples. South America, Central America, Africa and hey, how about Israel where we dropped a whole nation state on the local Palestinians?
Only took 50 years to get over dividing Germany. Prognosis on North and South Korea anyone? We’re not alone. Or at least we shouldn’t be. iirc Britain, France, Spain and a few other countries “helped” create these quagmires. Easy solution would be to take it to the UN, except that body acts a bit too much like our own US Senate with lobbyists keen on continuing to demand access to other peoples’ resources.
Some might say the path forward requires some tricky rebalancing.
Sorry Nick. You did ask the question. But. Answers? All we have for you this morning is more questions.
1Well, it looks like Putin is trying to put the Soviet band back together. That can’t be what you have in mind.
Haiti and the Dominican Republic have always been separate, one speaking Creole French and the other Spanish. Haiti was the first country to see a successful slave revolt and was punished and ostracized by the international community to discourage that kind of thing. It has never really caught up. I can see why the D.R. doesn’t want to be wholly responsible for its cycles of hurricane, earthquake and epidemic, which usually affect both countries. Helping Haiti to a decent life is the responsibility of the whole world, as you say, but right now we’re all preoccupied with our own political and climate disasters.
2The United States is not blameless when it comes to the situation in Haiti. We haven’t exactly been a friend.
3No doubt for most Haitians, the worst day in the DR is far better than the best day in Haiti.
4