A mess of you have asked me why Battleground Texas didn’t work.
I’ve kinda been coy because of Reagan’s 11th Commandment. However, I am not truly convinced that these people have the total interest of the Democratic Party at heart. One thing is clear, however, they are capitalists. And boy howdy!, did they ever prove that.
The best story I’ve seen on the matter is in the Austin American Statesman.
The Davis campaign boasted of raising more than $36 million, nearly keeping pace with Abbott’s fundraising had he not embarked on the campaign with $21 million already in the bank. But that isn’t the whole story.
While the Abbott campaign had direct control over all its money, only about $22.3 million in contributions flowed directly to Davis; the rest was shuffled through two committees, with some of it returned to her mostly as in-kind contributions.
The middle men consultants got rich and candidates from the state house to the court house got screwed. There are so many lumps in the kitty litter that I doubt it will ever get cleaned out.
Regardless of personalities, the whole concept is deeply flawed.
The worst part is that they own the data that volunteers collected. If a candidate wants to use that data, she has to hire these particular consultants. It’s no secret that the guy who owns Battleground Texas also owns Ready for Hillary. At a Ready for Hillary meeting I attended, they readily admitted – even with some excitement – that we were supposed to go out and get email addresses and phone numbers for them which they, in turn, would “sell” to Hillary.
Retail politics.
Volunteers were not allowed to keep the data they collected at block walks and phone banks. This is data the local Democratic Party might want to use in a school board race or a state house race in two years. It’s gone from the grassroots and now owned by a retail organization. You pay to play.
However, it turns out that most of their data is as worthless as corn flake recipes. The “fellows” they hired for a pittance were given unrealistic goals. You cannot block walk 200 houses in one afternoon in Texas in the heat. I personally saw one fellow make up data and enter it into their database because the person over him was threatening to fire him. No data is better than bad data.
An old Texas farmer had trouble with people stealing his watermelons. So, he posted a sign on his fence that said, “One of these watermelons is poisoned and only I know which one. Good luck!” The same is true with untrustworthy data. It’s like having a peeing section in a swimming pool. You cannot rely on getting out of the pool smelling like roses.
Paul Stafford, the Democratic candidate in Dallas County’s House District 115, said he appreciated the help he got from Battleground Texas. But he said that at times its volunteers had a “lack of expertise.”
“There were some deficiencies that became more glaring as the election drew closer,” Stafford said.
In some cases, he said, Battleground representatives, using faulty voter data, knocked on the doors of people who opposed him.
“If you come into an organization that’s touting itself as having an ability to do X, Y and Z, and mobilizing voters, and candidates rely on that, we hope they can deliver that effectively and efficiently,” Stafford said. “When that doesn’t happen, it’s really disappointing.”
That is why their predictions about the outcome were so wildly and embarrassingly wrong.
There are going to be people who disagree with me. That’s fine. I quit needing new friends about 20 years ago and, to be honest, there’s a couple of old ones I’d just as soon be rid of. However, I think you’re going to see county chairs across this state come out to say they never saw where $36 million went.
For those who are truly interested, read the entire Statesman column. In my mind, it’s right on target.
There’s more troubles outlined here in the Washington Post.
I will eventually write something funny about Battleground Texas but right now, it just hurts too much. When you rely on people to do what they say they can do and then they fail so spectacularly and arrogantly, it takes a while to laugh. Meanwhile, Battleground Alaska sounds like a good idea to me.